84% Were Targeted by Scammers, Says AARP. Meet the Holiday Lineup

Picture the holiday season from the scammer’s side of the desk. Shoppers are busy, packages are everywhere, and everyone’s phone is buzzing. To a criminal, that isn’t chaos. It’s a business plan.

AARP’s 2026 holiday shopping and scams survey, reported by bigislandnow.com, lays out the whole playbook. Step one: run a fake online ad for something people want. Step two: send a fraudulent shipping message about a package. Step three: add a fake toll payment text, just for variety. Then come the gift cards that turn out to be duds and the donation requests that aren’t what they claim to be.

The scheme reaches a lot of people. ANR Market Research Consultants surveyed 1,801 U.S. adults who use the internet and shop during the holiday season, and 84% said they had been targeted by scammers or experienced at least one of these common types of fraud. Of the 47% who bought something after seeing an online ad, 39% said they experienced fraud after doing so.

As Kathy Stokes, senior director of fraud prevention programs at AARP, put it: “Criminals don’t take a break during the holidays.”

For families, this lands close to home. Our parents shop online, get texts about deliveries, give to causes they care about, and often love a good gift card, which puts them right in the path of every trick on this list. LanternPhish keeps an eye on scam news like this for families, and this survey is a great excuse for a quick, friendly check-in before the season gets hectic.

The Holiday Scam Starter Pack

  • The ad that’s a little too perfect. If a deal in an online ad looks amazing, type the store’s real web address yourself instead of tapping the ad.
  • The mystery package text. In the past year, 47% of respondents got a fake shipping alert, so check any order on the retailer’s own site rather than through a texted link.
  • The toll you never owed. Another 44% received a text about a fake toll payment, and a real toll balance can always be checked on the official toll website.
  • The gift card with nothing on it. 35% have given or received a gift card with no balance, so inspect the packaging for tampering and hang on to the receipt.
  • The donation request that feels off. 31% received a donation request that seemed fake or suspicious, and the safest way to give is through the charity’s own website.
  • The countdown clock. Pressure to pay or click right now is a scammer’s favorite tool, because thinking it over is their least favorite thing you can do.
  • The strange way to pay. Any request to settle a bill with gift cards is a giant flashing sign that something is wrong.

The Five-Minute Phone Call

You don’t need a lecture or a slideshow. A relaxed conversation works best. Here’s one way it could go:

Hey, I just read about a survey on holiday scams and thought of you, mostly because I’m getting these texts too.

Apparently a lot of people are getting fake package and toll texts this time of year.

If you get one, could you check on the store’s website instead of clicking the link? I’m doing the same thing.

And if anyone ever asks you to pay something with a gift card, that’s a scam every time.

If something feels weird, just call me. I’d honestly love to help, and two heads are better than one.

Notice the “we’re in this together” tone. Your parents have spotted plenty of nonsense in their lifetimes. This is just new nonsense.

Already Clicked, Called Back, or Paid? Start Here

It happens to smart, careful people all the time. The key is to move quickly and calmly.

  • Call the bank or card issuer. Use the number printed on the back of the card, explain what happened, and ask about stopping or disputing the charge.
  • Contact the gift card company. If money went out on a gift card, reach the company that issued it right away and keep the card and receipt.
  • Change passwords. Start with email and banking, especially for any account they logged into through a suspicious link, and use a fresh password for each.
  • Turn on two-step verification. That extra code makes a stolen password much less useful to a crook.
  • Save the evidence. Take screenshots of texts, ads, and receipts before deleting anything.
  • Report it. File a report at reportfraud.ftc.gov, and for internet-based fraud, also at ic3.gov.
  • Watch the statements. Keep an eye on bank and card activity for the next few months for anything unfamiliar.
  • Ignore the recovery pitch. Anyone who contacts them offering to get the money back for a fee is often running a second scam.
  • Skip the blame. Embarrassment keeps people quiet, and quiet is exactly what scammers count on.

One more seasonal note: 30% of respondents said they had a package stolen from outside their home. If your parents are expecting deliveries, offering to grab them or suggesting a pickup option can save a lot of holiday grumbling.

The Bottom Line

Scammers are counting on the holiday rush to keep everyone too busy to notice. Your family can flip that script: one quick call, a few shared red flags, and a standing promise to double-check anything odd together. Bring that to the season and the scammers end up with the coal.

Want to practice on a fake one first?

That is exactly why LanternPhish exists. We keep tabs on scams like this one so your family hears about them early, and LanternPhish lets you practice spotting them with safe, fake scams that look like the real thing but can’t cost anyone a dime.

A few practice rounds and the red flags start jumping out on their own. Try LanternPhish with your family.